Cognitive Block

Why Perfectionism Causes Writer's Block (And How to Fix It)

Writer's Block
Quick Takeaways
  • Editing while drafting fills up working memory
  • Draft and edit on different days
  • Most people improve by session 4-6

What Is Cognitive Block?

Thinking about writing gets in the way of writing. We have ideas. We have drive. But the drafting stalls.

Research found three forms:[1]

  • Editing too much while drafting
  • Rigid rules about the process
  • Too much planning up front

Only 13% of blocks are purely cognitive. But 40-50% have a cognitive part.

Working Memory Overload

Writing uses three tasks at once. All three draw from our executive function system:

  1. Planning (what to say)
  2. Putting words down (how to say it)
  3. Fixing (checking quality)
Research

Kellogg, R. T. (1996). A Model of Working Memory in Writing

We can't max out fluency, storage, and quality all at once.

Working memory holds about 7 items. Planning takes 3 slots. Writing takes 3. Fixing takes 3. With perfectionism on, the total is too high. The system breaks.

Diagram showing working memory container being overwhelmed by planning, translation, and revision processes each requiring ~3 units, exceeding the 7±2 item capacity
When planning, translation, and revision compete for limited working memory, cognitive overload occurs

Five Rigid Rules That Block Us

These five types of rules cause blocks:

1. Editing Rules (Most Common)

  • "Sentences must be perfect before moving forward"
  • "First drafts should be polished"
  • "Real writers don't need revision"

2. Planning Rules

  • "Complete outlining required before writing"
  • "Must know the ending before starting"

3. Quantity Rules

  • "Good writing happens quickly"
  • "Slow writing indicates lack of talent"

4. Talent Rules

  • "Real writers feel inspired, not stuck"
  • "Hard writing means I lack talent"

5. Tone Rules

  • "I must always sound formal"
  • "Simple words mean simple thinking"
Five categories of rigid rules: Editing Rules, Planning Rules, Quantity Rules, Creativity Rules, and Authority Rules, each shown with an X symbol indicating they create blocks
Five categories of rigid rules that create cognitive blocks

Four Signs of Cognitive Block

Keystroke research shows four clear signs:

  1. Quick Delete: Type a few words, erase them, retype
  2. Long Pauses: 5+ seconds between words
  3. More Pausing Than Typing: Time stalls on each line
  4. Going Back: Scroll up and rewrite done work
Four keystroke research findings: Immediate Deletion pattern, Word-Level Pauses (5+ seconds), High Pause Ratio, and Recursive Revision loops
Keystroke research reveals four observable signatures of cognitive blocks

What Works

Need help right now? Our guide to fast fixes for perfectionism blocks has the quickest steps. Below is the full list.

Tier 1: Strong Evidence

1. Split Drafting from Editing
  • Set a 25-45 minute timer
  • Write nonstop. No edits.
  • Do not reread while drafting
  • Edit later. Best: a new day.
2. Timed Writing
  • Set a 25-minute timer
  • No edits until the timer ends
  • Take 5-minute breaks between rounds
  • The clock beats perfectionism
3. Write a Full Outline First
  • Make an outline before drafting
  • List key points and proof
  • Follow the outline while drafting
  • This frees up working memory

Tier 2: Some Proof

  • Test Our Rules: Ask where they came from. Find proof they are wrong.
  • Freewrite: Write 10-15 minutes daily. Never reread it.
  • Bad First Drafts: We can fix bad prose. We can't fix a blank page.

What Does Not Work

  • A walk (helps the body, not the mind)
  • Prompts (helps planning, not writing)
  • New setting (a behavioral fix, not cognitive)
  • "Push through" (makes the overload worse)
Share

References

  1. Rose, M. (1984). Writer's block: The cognitive dimension. Southern Illinois University Press. ↩